Custom Cakes · New Baden
Made for your
most important moments.
Every custom cake is designed and baked from scratch — for weddings, birthdays, and everything worth celebrating.
Our Work
Built to be remembered.
Every cake is a collaboration. Here’s a look at some of our recent work — weddings, birthdays, and milestones.
Our Custom Cake Process
We believe the best results come from a clear, collaborative process. Here's what to expect.
- 1
Consultation
Share your vision, event details, and timeline. We'll discuss design direction and availability.
- 2
Design & Proposal
We create a custom design and pricing proposal tailored to your event.
- 3
Creation & Delivery
Your cake is crafted fresh and delivered or prepared for pickup on your event date.
Common Questions
Before you reach out.
We’re located at 115 W Hanover Street in downtown New Baden, Illinois.
We’re open Tuesday through Saturday, 4:30 a.m. to 7:00 p.m., and closed Sunday and Monday. We bake fresh every morning, so popular items can sell out. Come early for the best selection.
You can order online anytime, or stop in during business hours for everyday items. For custom cakes or larger special orders, give us a call at (618) 588-4233 or visit us in person so we can talk through the details.
Yes! We design and bake custom cakes from scratch for birthdays, weddings, and every kind of celebration. Browse our custom cakes gallery for inspiration, then call (618) 588-4233 to start your order.
Yes, pickup is available during our regular business hours, Tuesday through Saturday. We’ll have your order boxed and ready to go.
Scratch-made breads, pastries, and donuts, plus specialty items like cream horns and custard bismarcks, and custom cakes for any occasion. Fresh every morning; stop in to see the day’s case.
The Worn Whisk opened in 2026 under owner Kristen Rogers, carrying on New Baden’s long-loved bakery tradition on Hanover Street. Kristen worked in this very bakery years ago and is proud to keep it a cornerstone of the community.